Why “Slow Swinger = Low Compression” Is Misleading | The Truth About this Strongly Debated Myth
Transcript
What is up my fellow golf ball addicts? I don't get to do videos like this very often but this has been actually pretty heavily requested over the last couple weeks and it's something I made a video about. I wanted to talk about it. There's a lot of good information in here. I hope that kind of helps some you know some of you get steered in the right direction. So without further ado let's just kind of dive right in. This is a video about one of the biggest misunderstandings in golf I think and especially as time goes on that gets worse which is the idea that if you are a slower swing golfer you should play a softer model. In this video I'm going to kind of go into depth about what that means, why I myself am one of those people who do recommend slower golf balls and where the robotic testing kind of muddies up the water a little bit and how maybe we can clear it up. Let's dive right in. As always I do independent golf ball reviews from the average golfer perspective. So if you're new here like, comment, subscribe, all the free stuff. I have a membership that just starts a dollar a month but if you want unbiased golf ball reviews from a guy who's been playing a lot of golf for a long time and you want to know more about golf, I have a I've been doing it for six years and just does it for the love of the game. We'd love to have you around. We have an amazing community. Some of the people in this community, actually you know what, no, all the people in this community are some of the best ever and I'll tell you what, there's not a better golfing community around in my opinion. So we'd love for you to stick around too. Okay so let's, it started with a video right and this is actually, I'm going to give a shout out to this channel right here. This is Golfing with Graham. He's a newer channel guy and this is the video I kept getting tagged in when people would email me or whatever because he did this test. He did it with a driver where he essentially did 85 mile an hour and he tested the theory that you know can a slower swing golfer you know compress a Pro V1 or an X model golf ball whatever and it's a great video. I'd give it an A minus honestly. I thought it was very well done and a lot of detail, a lot of attention in there. I mean a couple minor things but honestly Graham, if you're watching this, great job buddy. Seriously, I like the video a lot but he did commit one of the fallacies and it's not his fault. I don't blame him. What happens is over time, I don't know the word for it but I played a game when I was in school and what they would do is they would whisper something in the first kid's ear like a phrase right like Jimmy's going to the basketball game and then he had to turn to the person to his left and whisper you know Jimmy's going to the basketball and you did that throughout the whole class. Well as you know by the time you got to the final student, it no longer was that phrase anymore. It was Billy's going to the moon and you're like how did it get so you know because sometimes as you tell it from one person to another that can happen. That's what this is kind of a case of. When I was growing up, people said the same thing. They said oh yeah you know if you're getting older in age or whatever if you have a slower swinger, play a softer golf ball but over time, golf balls have changed and golf equipment has changed and golf technology has changed and golfers have changed. We have different types of people playing golf now. It's not the country club you know elite anymore. Now, it's just regular dudes who you know are like party bros. You know it's a total different. There's all kinds of stuff right. We could go forever but it's a different world and now people are still trying to use the same one-liner logic it's not black and white. Nothing in golf is. I've learned that over six years. There's nothing black and white about golf and this phrase sometimes can come off as black and white. So, there are three main fallacies I think when it comes to this phrase right and let's go ahead and start with the first one. This is the one that actually Graham in his video commits here and that's that you only look at the driver right. Now, this is actually something that separates my channel from a lot of other channels. I've heard several people and even when I'm fitting people, I get told all the time. The driver is the big stick and it's all that matters. That's just not true. You got 14 clubs in your bag. When you're fitting a golf ball or whatever golf equipment anything you can't just look at one club. You have to look at the entire bag right. This is my driver that someone sent to me this year. It was actually next round. Shout out next round. This is the QI 35 from TaylorMade. Look at this thing. I mean it's got carbon and it's got titanium face and it's got parts from the space shuttle on here. Of course, you're going to be able to compress any golf ball with this thing regardless of your swing speed. One, it's the longest club. Two, it's got all these spaceship like parts. You know what I'm saying? Carbon. It's just it's it's got the most technology of basically any club out there and you know you even fit the shaft to yourself most of the time. Like it it's a legit club that is designed to swing fast and compress golf balls. It's 460 cc most of the time unless you're playing a mini driver or something. Look, you get my point. There's so much there that of course you're going to be able to compress a pro v1 when you're swinging 85 mile an hour. That's never been my beef. I know you can. So what I usually tell people when I'm fitting right is I if I say hey you're playing an X model golf ball you're swinging 85 mile an hour. I know you can hit the driver right and you know what your fairway woods you're probably still pretty good too. But what happens when you get to your five or six iron. Now all of a sudden we have an iron right. This is my five iron and as you can see it's a lot different. Sure it might be heavier as far as the head but especially depending on if you have forged or cavity back whatever my atoms were really light. So it depends right. Now if you hit a ball right in the center sure you can probably still now you're down to probably what 78 78 to 80 mile an hour with a five iron give or take right. But the point is is are you going to compress that golf ball if you hit it in the middle. Yeah probably but anything outside of that probably not. It's probably going to punish you pretty decently not like a softer model would. Now not just five iron. What if we go to seven iron. What if we go to nine iron. What if we go to wedges. And a lot of people will push back on me at this point say well Nick what why does that compression matter when we're getting into wedges and stuff. I'm only three quarters swinging them. Well good point. But a three quarter swing for me is a guy who swings 105 with the driver. A three quarter sandwich for me goes about 105. But for someone who swings 85 with the driver they might only be getting 70 out of it 80 maybe if they're lucky. So that is a difference. You're going to compress it differently. And I can tell you from experience you're going to get a different spin number. You're not going to compress it as much to get in the grooves there. Softer golf balls really absorb into the club and catch the grooves a little bit more. Now you might say well Nick but the other ones are urethane. You don't have to play a softer you know ionomer golf ball. They do make urethane models that are softer. So it's not just about that. It matters throughout your whole bag. You're not going to get the proper launch angles. You're not going to get the proper you know forgiveness. There's a lot of factors that go into play. And I'm looking at it from your entire bag. And most of the time I'm looking at it from your entire bag. And most of the time I'm looking at it from your entire bag. And most of the time when people try to make this argument to me or they have questions about it they're like well with my driver I still hit it pretty good. Well of course right. It's got the most technology so I get that. The second fallacy is a little bit of extremism here right. So most of the time when I'm fitting someone I do say like hey you should play a softer golf ball. And it's amazing how far they immediately take it right. Because compression you know my range on what I've tested is my lowest I've seen is 51. And my highest I've seen is like 115, 120. Somewhere in that range because compression only goes up so high the gauge. But it's like 117 we'll say right. So it's a pretty good spectrum. When someone's playing a MaxFly Tour X and it's 115 compression and I say you know you're getting up there in age. Your swing's gone down to 85 mile an hour. I think you should play a softer golf ball. They immediately go oh well I don't really like the Strixon soft feel or the Callaway Super Soft. Well who said anything about that? That's a pretty big jump. Am I right? Like you're going from 115. compression all the way down to like 75, 70, 65. I'm not necessarily talking about that. I just mean a softer ball. Instead of the MaxFly Tour X try the regular Tour if it fits you okay. If not try the Tour S or maybe try the Revolution. That's like a 90s compression. I think a lot of people hear that play a softer ball and their mind immediately just goes to like the Super Soft and they're like well I don't want to play a two piece. No one's saying that. You can still play a three piece or a four piece. Most of the time three piece because four pieces are pretty good. But you can still play a three piece your thing golf ball that has 80 compression, 85, 90, 95. Nobody's saying you should immediately make that jump to that big of a degree. Like those 60 compression golf balls even I know they're made for like the super super senior slow. You know my mom drives at 150 yards. She benefits a ton from a 51 compression golf ball. Now the last fallacy kind of just plays in here all together and it really comes from most of the time. I'd say 80 and 59, 60 and all you gotta naturally do is take your 10 horse Ranch by the 10 of these we go around and I can see if anybody has had $10,000 Montefort but who has the 15 sh tidak wisol for $10,000 hill drive? Well, I was gonna I'd I've got to be trapped here golf ball on here. It doesn't benefit ön at all to me. I mean it's not my turn but it goes to propos. Right. What happens next. ¿How many Bolívares que hiciste usted? robotic golf test says that I can play a Pro V1X as a 70 mile an hour swinger because it got pretty good distance with the driver, my immediate response is going to be, okay, how good's your ball striking? Because are you telling me you're that good to where you're going to have the same? Because look, me, I'm a seven handicap. My ball striking is average at best sometimes. That's why I have to do multiple shots when I do my testing and take the best 10. But like, they're still kind of all over the place. Like the idea that you're going to just get bam, bam, bam every single time. It's not going to happen. Golf balls react so differently depending on the attack angle and whether you sweep like I do, or whether you really hit down on it. It's impossible to judge one robot swing that is just the same swing every single time and compare it to somebody who has not only a different swing from the rip, from the rip, just their normal swing, but also the idea that it's going to be different and have variances in it. It's just not a good comparison. It's apples to oranges. Heck, it's apples to hot dogs. So those are the three fallacies. Now I do want to talk about some numbers I got. I went out and did my own test and you're going to see a couple differences in how I did my test and how Graham did his, even though we did them basically the same, we got a little bit different results. And I want to talk about that. So let me grab my tablet here. So I want to give you a little bit of context before I dive into these numbers. And that's why I myself recommend usually softer golf balls for the slower swing speeds, right? And it's really, it just kind of boils down to two things. One, forgiveness. Softer golf balls forgive you more. And yes, do they go as far with the driver sometimes or have as much ball speed? Not always. Sometimes they are farther, but they usually don't have as much ball speed. I'm fully aware of that. But throughout the entire bag, they're more forgiving. And a lot of the time they get a higher ball launch. And you might say, well, does everyone need that? No, but a lot of seniors do. And a lot of guys who are losing that swing speed do because the slower your swing speed, most of the time what happens is you lose that launch anyway. And what I have found is even testing at 95 mile an hour, the more a golf ball carries, the farther it goes, just period. I mean, there are some golfers who can get away if they're really fast with getting that low penetrating flight, but nine times out of 10 from an average golfer perspective, the higher launch means you're going to get more carry. It just does. So with that being said, keeping that in mind, if we look at these numbers, I tested a Pro V1 and I tested a Speedsoft Inc, which is one of my favorite two-piece golf balls out there. And shout out, Nick, you're going to see this as well. And you're going to love this, but Speedsoft Inc is one of my favorite two-piece golf balls out there. And essentially these are the clubs I did it with as well. I did a wedge test with my full face RTX Cleveland wedge. And then I did a driver test, of course, with that QI 35 you saw. And then I also did a iron test with the nine iron just to kind of showcase what it would do there. So again, what I did was I hit 20 shots with each. I took the best 10. So this is going to give you pretty close numbers, but I want to go over what those small differences are and why I do sometimes think they matter. If we look at the first data point here, we are going to start with the 60 yard spin. And as you can see, I actually got about roughly 150, 160 more RPM with the Speedsoft, but that's relatively close. We can call that a wash if you want. But the main difference between the two is going to be that launch angle. As you can see, 32.1 compared to 26.7. That's what I'm talking about. When I say softer golf balls, they get up in the air a little bit easier. That Speedsoft may only have 150, 160 more RPM, but it's going to have a much better descent angle. It's going to go high in the air, it's going to use that spin, and basically it's going to come down and just land. And something I've seen with the Speedsoft Inc that I've seen with a lot of other two-piece golf balls or even softer three-piece models, when they get high like that and they have that good spin and they come down, maybe you've seen it, it hits and just kind of stays exactly where it's at. It doesn't hop at all. It just hits and sometimes it'll roll maybe a foot towards you, or maybe it'll even just hit and just stay, but it comes down basically at a straight angle. And that's what this golf ball does. So do I think the Pro V1 is going to stop really any different? No, it's all going to be relative and similar, but I do like the fact that it gets a better descent angle. It has a little bit more spin, but more importantly, it launches higher. And so for a slower swinger, I recommend that. But you might say, well, you know what, Nick? No, I still love my Pro V1. I'm fine with the lower launch. Cool. There's nothing wrong with that, but that's the reason I recommend it. Now let's go into nine iron. And again, if we look at nine iron, these numbers are relatively the same, 124.2, 123.6. The Pro V1 actually went farther, because again, we'll talk about that in a second with the descent angle, but both the speeds were the same. Ball speed's fine. Now, again, when we look at the spin, 5,928 compared to 5,600. So that's a 328 difference. Now, is that a huge difference? No, not huge, but look at the launch angle, 20.1 compared to 18. So that's a 2.1 degree difference. And what is significant about that is the fact, again, like we just talked about, you're going to get it higher in the air. Some might say it's ballooning at that point. It depends on the golfer. I mean, obviously it wasn't ballooning for me because I got the same distance, but higher launch, higher spin, better descent angle, more forgiveness. Again, it's a lot of small stuff, right? It's not that you couldn't play the Pro V1. It's just that why would I, as a golf ball fitter, recommend a $60 a dozen golf ball when you could play a Speedsoft Inc. for 25 bucks a dozen and get similar performance and get it up in the air a little bit better, right? Or if there's minor tweaks that are better. Golf balls are all about fitting, but you see what I mean. And if we look at driver here, now you'll notice there is a little bit difference here compared to what like Graham got and some other tests have done, but I'll show you why in a second. 202.1 compared to 195. I actually got more distance with the Speedsoft Inc. And overall it was about six yards. So it's not huge, but look at ball speed. Ball speed's exactly the same. So it's not even a matter of coming off the clubface. It's just about optimization. The Speedsoft had 2,251 spin. I got a little bit more with the Pro V1 for some reason, 2,643. And then if you look at the launch angle, that's the big key difference. 14 compared to 12, well, 11.9, but again, a two degree difference. And that once again is where you're seeing it. The forgiveness, the slightly higher launch. Now, what do all those numbers actually mean? Well, they're relatively close. And this is the problem with robotic testing. You see the robotic testing and you see all these numbers that are so close. You see the numbers that are so close. You see super close to each other. And people will tell me, well, Nick, there's not a lot of difference between these golf balls. They're all just so close. And the numbers are the same. And, you know, we're only a mile an hour off. That's sometimes how robotic testing can muddy the water. What these numbers tell you is that golf balls always will and always have been about fitting. What do you need? Do you need a high launch? Do you need high spin? Do you need low spin? Do you need more bendability? Do you need more forgiveness? Do you, do you play on tighter courses? Do you need more bendability? Do you play on, you know, bigger open championship courses? Do you play from the back tees? Do you play from the front tees? There are a million questions that go into a golf ball fitting that I do. And it ultimately comes down to finding the right golf ball. I don't care if it's a two piece. I don't care if it's a four piece. I don't care if it's 60 compression. I don't care if it's 120 compression. I have to find what you're looking for and what is going to complement your game. What is going to amplify your strengths and help bring up some of your weaknesses. That's all those numbers. I'll see you next time. Bye. So I hope this has kind of shed some light a little bit. Again, what it is is it's, it's not that people should be playing slower golf balls or, you know, softer golf balls because their swing has gone down. It's just that it depends on what you need because for most people, most average Joes, we're looking to not spend a lot of money and we're looking for the most forgiveness and to have a good time. That's not going to be a pro V1. It's not designed that way. It's designed to be bent left and right. It's designed. They did not invent, I promise you, they did not invent a pro V1 with the idea of, yeah, it just goes nice and straight, you know, just hit it right in the fairway and then hit it right on the grid. That's not what they designed that ball for.…
